Selayang Dog-Catching (Killing) Contest

  • Click here to become an Official Member of BMW Club Malaysia Download Form

DrGoh

Club Guest
Joined
Dec 10, 2004
Messages
86
Points
0
I have reported this to the Humane Society of Malaysia, however, I urge Selayang folks to be careful of letting your dogs out on the streets. I do not wish to stir up sensitive discussions.Just a friendly reminder that Selayang streets are unsafe for dogs.Link: http://www.mps.gov.my/default01.htmGod bless...
 
I dunno abt the killing along the way...but the rules states that the dogs have to be alive to be accounted for.
 
Wow...RM15k for top prize.

Maybe not so inhumane as the dogs have to be captured alive.:stupid:

But the question here is, is it appropriate for MPS to organise a dog hunting competition???:smokin:
 
I think basically what they are doing is instead of hiring some one, they are asking the public to organise amongst themselves to catch the dogs and pay them a paltry sum of RM39k where else if to hire some one it would be maybe RM80K...which come to this question...why suddenly this fellas so thrifty????....
 
1.

Pertandingan adalah antara Jawatankuasa Penduduk dalam kawasan pentadbiran Majlis Perbandaran Selayang.

2.

Tangkapan boleh dilaksanakan sama ada oleh Jawatankuasa Penduduk sendiri atau dengan menggunakan bantuan pihak-pihak tertentu. Majlis Perbandaran Selayang tidak bertanggungjawab atas upah penangkapan.

3.
Tangkapan dilaksanakan tanpa menjejaskan undang-undang Kecil 10(2)(a) Undang-undang Kecil Pelesenan Anjing dan Rumah Pembiakan Anjing (Majlis Perbandaran Selayang) 2005.

4.
Tangkapan hendaklah diserahkan hidup-hidup kepada urus setia pertandingan untuk pengiraan/audit. Gambar setiap ekor tangkapan juga hendaklah dikemukakan
sebagai bukti tangkapan.

5.
Pertandingan akan berjalan sepanjang masa.


from the website
 
So basically, there is no end to this competition as "Pertandingan akan berjalan sepanjang masa"... hence, there is no deadline.. So the dog catchers will have to keep their captured dogs alive by feeding them till the council gives the "Ok, u may pass me d dogs now" signal... have u heard of a competition that has no deadline?
 
Its like a WANTED poster, with the reward at the bottom... disgusting!
 
From The Star (10/9/07)

Catching strays not for the man on the street
VALLEY VIEWS WITH FREDERICK FERNANDEZ

THERE is going to be a dogathon of a different kind in Selayang soon and the “barking” has never been louder.
Selayang Municipal Council’s (MPS) decision to hold a competition to rid the place of stray dogs drew a lot of flak from animal rights groups and pet owners.
Clearly, the uproar is over the council’s unconventional, if not risky, approach to resolving the high number of strays in the municipality.
Cash prizes of up to RM15,000 would be dished out to any individual or group that could catch more than 150 stray dogs within six months. A sum of RM20 would be given for each stray dog caught alive.
Yet again, we get another local government introducing a dogmatic programme without getting the people’s or even expert feedback.
The council should have sought assistance from the Veterinary Services Department and groups like the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, Furry Friends Farm, Petpositive, Roar and others before introducing such a competition.
Catching stray dogs is no easy task. It is even dangerous. Only a trained dog catcher can handle the job. And, even for the latter, it is no easy task.
A few years back, a neighbour of mine contacted the local municipal council to complain about six stray dogs loitering in the neighbourhood.
The dogs had attacked a few passers-by and motorcyclists before this. The canines also rummaged for food from garbage bins, creating a mess outside homes.
When a team of dog catchers arrived one fine morning, the dogs ran helter-skelter and only two were caught.
The dogs, as if aware that it was a “do or die” attempt, put up a fight with the catchers.
By organising the competition, the council is clearly compromising not only the safety of the dogs, but also the individuals who take part.
Those desperate for quick money, like drug addicts may jump on the bandwagon. A brutal encounter awaits should this happens.
The untrained dog catchers may resort to using whatever they can, maybe spears, iron rods and parangs to capture these dogs.
The end result would be a lot of injured and wounded dogs handed over to MPS.
Did I mention a neighbour’s dog going missing all of a sudden one morning, too?
And, the man who lives next door coming out to breathe fresh air again - gleefully.
It is imperative to look at this delicate issue comprehensively and come up with a workable solution rather than to engage in a war of words in the media.
The council probably never gave a thought as to where these dogs would be housed. The canines could pose a danger while under captivity.
If MPS has a shortage of manpower in catching strays, they should seek the assistance of neighbouring councils to help for now at least.
They should also train volunteers, not ask everyone in the neighbourhood to take on the task. Another programme MPS could implement is to seek the help of the veterinary services department and animal rights groups to spay and neuter strays to control their breeding.
And yes, clear the rubbish outside homes on time, too. Unless these measures are considered, the stray dogs in Selayang are still the underdogs in their battle to escape the harsh treatment of this”dog-eat-dog-world” of ours.
 
Disgusting !!!

1. What happens if a dog steps just outside the owners gate ?
2. What if this competetion becomes so competetive that people break into houses just to steal dogs ?
3. Dont cats get the same fate since their shit smells bad and they constantly scratch our furniture and our UDM's nice paintwork.
4. What if the owner is about to catch the dog and one of these freaks catch them and no matter how the owner begs the fellow doest give back his dog ?

Another way for our brainless govt to take the easy way out. Well I will feel sorry for the person who even tries to touch any one of my dogs.
 
On September 11th 2007 (Tuesday) at 10am, SPCA, PETPOSITIVE, ROAR and other animal welfare organisations will be gathering at the Majlis Perbandaran Selayang office to hand over a memorandum to the President of MPS. The document will call for an immediate end to the competition and urge the municipal to spay/ neuter actively to control the dog overpopulation, formulate and enforce effective legislation to prevent pet owners from abandoning their pets, and embark on educational efforts to promote Responsible Pet Ownership. We invite all friends of SPCA, animal welfare groups, animal lovers from far and near and members of the media to come and show your support on this important day.

Let's unite in our stand against the inhumane treatment of stray and homeless animals.

Majlis Perbandaran Selayang,
MENARA MPS.
PERSIARAN 3, BANDAR BARU SELAYANG,
68100 BATU CAVES

For more information, please contact SPCA Public Relations officer Jacinta Johnson at the SPCA office at 42565312/ 42535179 or at 012-2881421
 
MPS --- you suck !!! first foremost you've been sucking our income via taxes and now you're gonna suck those animals out there .. Cheechhh

why don't you MPS use the money to spay the dogs .... ?? dammit
 
I don't see any alternative suggestion from first pages how to tackle "no owner" dogs around , only usual complaint ............... ?

I also like to know how to make pet owners bring bag to collect their pet poo, ? Any suggestion ...........

FYI , I live surround by dog owners. I calculated 56 of them and none even care to bring the bag ......., I pity my kids living in place where full of dog poo around.

Appreciate suggestion than complaint around .........

Cheers mate
 
you guys have any idea where some of the dogs end up? DBKL has a similar stray dogs unit.

i've helped organised numerous trainings for our doctors/surgeons who are at the beginning of their career. some of these dogs will be sent to the institute of medical research (next to KLGH) whenever there is a request from the institute. they will be used as the animal model for trainings/practices of surgical procedures. yes, sadly its true..the dogs will be operated upon, in the animal lab of the institute.

in the western countries, pigs are normally used as their anatomy is in many ways quite similar to human beings' (gastrointestinal organ/liver), and these pigs are reared from farms especially for this purpose, and believe it or not, these pigs will not end up dead after the procedures because they are cared for like a real patient! gas will be given during the procedures and the pigs do not feel any pain at all. after the surgery is completed the pigs will be revived, and sent back to the farms.

the same can't be said about those dogs which end up in this lab. we do not have any adequate equipments to keep the dogs alive. they will all be injected with a dose of anesthetics/painkiller which will knock them unconscious, and most of the time, before the procedure is over, hardly have any life left in them.

just to share what i've seen. i don't know what happen to the dogs that were sent to MPS or DBKL, but i don't think they have better fate than these bunch
 
whenever any government instituitions are involved/highlighted in any of the postings, we get the 'Usual Suspects' putting their 2 sens by totalling sidelining and ignoring the main issue.... which is CRUETY TO ANIMALS!!! I guess most of them suffer from myopic views....

nothing justifies killing, which is wat will happen to these animals eventually...
 
blackrobe;246542 said:
whenever any government instituitions are involved/highlighted in any of the postings, we get the 'Usual Suspects' putting their 2 sens by totalling sidelining and ignoring the main issue.... which is CRUETY TO ANIMALS!!! I guess most of them suffer from myopic views....

nothing justifies killing, which is wat will happen to these animals eventually...

Vegetarian eating Shark meat ?? :smokin:
 
thsaw99;246403 said:
you guys have any idea where some of the dogs end up? DBKL has a similar stray dogs unit.

i've helped organised numerous trainings for our doctors/surgeons who are at the beginning of their career. some of these dogs will be sent to the institute of medical research (next to KLGH) whenever there is a request from the institute. they will be used as the animal model for trainings/practices of surgical procedures. yes, sadly its true..the dogs will be operated upon, in the animal lab of the institute.

in the western countries, pigs are normally used as their anatomy is in many ways quite similar to human beings' (gastrointestinal organ/liver), and these pigs are reared from farms especially for this purpose, and believe it or not, these pigs will not end up dead after the procedures because they are cared for like a real patient! gas will be given during the procedures and the pigs do not feel any pain at all. after the surgery is completed the pigs will be revived, and sent back to the farms.

the same can't be said about those dogs which end up in this lab. we do not have any adequate equipments to keep the dogs alive. they will all be injected with a dose of anesthetics/painkiller which will knock them unconscious, and most of the time, before the procedure is over, hardly have any life left in them.

just to share what i've seen. i don't know what happen to the dogs that were sent to MPS or DBKL, but i don't think they have better fate than these bunch

interesting la your story.....what happened to the pigs after they were sent back to the farm in healthy condition? they just milk the susu izzit? or just let them roam around looking cute until they die of old age :)
 
ICEMAN 13;246338 said:
MPS --- you suck !!! first foremost you've been sucking our income via taxes and now you're gonna suck those animals out there .. Cheechhh

why don't you MPS use the money to spay the dogs .... ?? dammit

I AGREE... MPS, U SUCKS... :thefinger:
every dogs on the street hav their right to live...
and i beleive these dogs are more compassionate than u all...
 
Top Bottom